Home ›
Alternatives › GiveSmart Alternatives
Alternatives GuideData current as of November 2026
8 Best GiveSmart Alternatives for Nonprofit Events in 2026
Most nonprofits searching for GiveSmart alternatives have run good events on it, often for years, sometimes since it was Auctions By Cellular or Gesture. What changed is usually the renewal.
A $3,000 annual quote comes in higher than last year's; the database manager points out that event data still reaches Raiser's Edge NXT through an import tool; and the events coordinator mentions that the backend has to be relearned every time the team opens it for a new campaign.
That's the reader this guide is for: a development director and an events coordinator re-evaluating an established auction platform at renewal, with a database administrator checking what actually happens to the data afterward and a board weighing the annual contract against one or two events.
So what is the best GiveSmart alternative? It depends on which of three things you're shopping for, and most readers arrive comparing all three without realizing it.
Full event platforms run tickets, tables, sponsorships, check-in, silent auction, and paddle raise in one system and are the like-for-like replacements. Auction-focused tools run the bidding well and leave ticketing and the CRM to something else.
General-purpose giving platforms are free or near-free and have added auction features onto a donation-form core. We segmented the eight alternatives below into those groups so you can discard two-thirds of the list quickly.
We assessed each alternative on event depth, how it integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT, total cost at a $200,000 gala, and its support model on the night. We built Trellis, so read our assessment of our own product with that in mind.
The rubric is published below, and it's the same one we use on our best-of guides, so a platform's score is identical wherever it appears.
The verdict in a nutshell
We evaluated eight alternatives to GiveSmart for US nonprofits raising $200K or more a year through events. Nonprofits evaluating a move typically prioritize Raiser's Edge NXT integration depth and total cost over feature count.
Trellis, our own product, is the best overall alternative for teams on Raiser's Edge NXT: the only platform that actually integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT in real time, with reconciliation done the same night instead of over the following weeks, and at a flat $5,000 a year.
OneCause is the closest like-for-like replacement with staff on site. Handbid is the best pick for teams that want native bidder apps, and BetterWorld is the best free option.
Trellis
Best Overall Alternative
OneCause
Closest Like-for-Like Replacement
Handbid
Best for Native Bidder Apps
BetterWorld
Best Free Option
Quick Comparison Table
Data is current as of November 2026, and pricing was verified against each vendor's published pricing page or review-site listing. GiveSmart itself does not appear as a row because it is the baseline every option is measured against; on our rubric, it scores 5.9.
About the Author
Justin Goodhew, Co-founder and CEO
Justin brings extensive expertise in nonprofit fundraising, donor engagement, and event technology. Through Trellis, he has helped organizations raise over $125 million across 500+ fundraising galas. His insights are shaped by firsthand experience working with nonprofits to simplify fundraising, improve event performance, and maximize mission-driven impact.
Why Nonprofits Look for a GiveSmart Alternative
GiveSmart is an established platform; support is the most praised thing in its reviews, and many readers of this page have run successful auctions on it for a decade.
The three reasons below are drawn from recurring patterns in Capterra, Software Advice, and TrustRadius reviews, not from a sales deck, and the first is partly a fit issue that GiveSmart itself has moved to address.
The annual price goes up, and the plan may not fit the calendar
The annual subscription is listed at about $3,000 with 3.5% to 3.95% card processing (the higher rate for American Express), and long-tenured reviewers describe the price for the same service going up considerably each year while they get less in return.
For an organization running one gala, a subscription sized for year-round campaigns is paying for breadth the team never opens.
In September 2026, Momentive, GiveSmart's parent, launched a Pay-As-You-Go option with no annual fee and a higher all-in transaction rate disclosed at signup, so for some readers the fix is a different GiveSmart plan rather than a different vendor.
Price the two models on your own numbers before you decide either way.
Raiser's Edge NXT data arrives through an import tool
GiveSmart lists Blackbaud Raiser's Edge among its integrations, and the documented path is Importacular NXT, a third-party import tool from Zeidman Development that names GiveSmart as a data source.
It's a real import tool with saved mappings, and it's still an export from GiveSmart followed by an import into Raiser's Edge NXT after every event, with matching and fund mapping done in the tool and no event participation records created.
Reviewers on Capterra wish GiveSmart integrated better with their CRM, and for a database administrator the import means batching, de-duplicating and re-attributing after each event, typically two to five weeks of work. The platform runs the night; the reconciliation afterward is where Blackbaud customers most often start looking.
Bryan Rurey, Director of Development Operations at Blessings in a Backpack, who moved seven chapters and 275 fundraising programs off GiveSmart, said it on stage at bbcon: "We were using GiveSmart as an organization. It's not a bad product. The product did everything that we asked it to do. I just wasn't going to spend two weeks or three weeks putting it all in the system."
Relearning the backend, and the night-of support question
Reviewers who use GiveSmart a handful of times a year describe a backend that's hard to understand and has to be relearned for every new event, while praising the chat support that walks them through it.
Onsite event staffing, once a selling point, is no longer a standard offering; the help center lists an emergency after-hours line for event night instead, and reviewers who have had staff describe them as hit or miss.
A May 2026 Capterra review describes being unable to sell gala tickets for ten days and support treating it as user error, which is one review against hundreds of positive ones, and also the kind of night a development director cannot afford once.
How We Evaluated These GiveSmart Alternatives
Every alternative was scored one to 10 on six criteria, then weighted. The weights and scores are the same ones we use on our gala and auction best-of guides, so a platform ranked here carries the same number there.
On the integration and reconciliation columns, a native real-time sync scores 10, an import plug-in or paid middleware scores 2 to 3, and a file export scores 1, because moving from weeks of reconciliation to one day is a tenfold difference, not a two-point one.
Reliability is scored on whether the platform runs the night without vendor staff, how much training volunteers need, and what happens if something breaks.
One factor matters more for a switcher than for a first-time buyer: migration. A platform that cannot import your item catalog, contact history, and sponsor list is a different proposition when your next gala is twelve weeks away, so Setup on every entry addresses it directly.
Our Scoring Methodology
Raiser's Edge NXT integration and reconciliation
25%
Direct real-time sync at constituent, gift, and participant level versus an import tool versus an export, and the reconciliation burden after the event
Donor and guest experience
20%
Login and app requirements, text-based giving, card entered once, drop-off at the moment of giving
Revenue drivers and tooling
20%
Tickets, tables, sponsorships, silent auction, paddle raise, overtime bidding, bid-to-donation conversion, upsells
Event-day reliability
15%
Uptime, runs without vendor staff, training volunteers need, what happens if something breaks
Reporting and reconciliation
10%
Receipting with fair market value split, fee handling, payouts matched to gifts
Pricing transparency and total cost
10%
Published pricing, platform fee plus processing, per-event versus annual, and the cost of a $200,000 gala
The 8 Best GiveSmart Alternatives for Galas and Auctions in 2026
What are the best alternatives to GiveSmart? Below, the eight platforms are ranked by score, grouped by what kind of tool each one is.
Trellis, OneCause, Greater Giving, Givergy, and Bloomerang Fundraising are full event platforms. Handbid is auction-focused. BetterWorld and Givebutter are general-purpose giving platforms with event features added.
Our top pick
#1
Trellis
Best for Galas and Auctions on Raiser's Edge NXTFundraising Tech Score: 9.6/10
Best for: organizations on Raiser's Edge NXT running one to three large events a year who are leaving GiveSmart because of the import step, the renewal price, or the night-of support question, and who do not require vendor staff in the room.
Platform Overview
Trellis is our event fundraising platform for galas, auctions, and golf tournaments.
If you use Raiser's Edge NXT and you raise over $200K a year through events, it's built for you.
Feature for feature, Trellis covers the same ground as GiveSmart: tickets, tables, sponsorships, check-in, mobile bidding, paddle raise, raffles, text-to-give, and guest messaging. The difference is that we integrate with Raiser's Edge NXT, and GiveSmart imports.
We're the only platform that actually integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT in real time, so tickets, sponsorships, winning bids, and pledges land on the right constituent records as they're sold, and the reconciliation that takes other platforms two to five weeks is finished the same day.
Giving is text-first, so any guest who can receive a text can bid and give; the platform takes the weight off your team before, during, and after the event, and pricing is a flat $5,000 a year.
More than 500 galas have raised over $170 million on Trellis, and it's the highest-rated and most-reviewed gala, auction, and ticketing application on the Blackbaud Marketplace, with a 4.7 rating and among the three or four most-reviewed applications on the entire Blackbaud Marketplace.
The 4 Problems We Built Trellis to Solve for Teams Leaving GiveSmart
The problem
The integration is an import tool with a logo on it.
The most common reason Blackbaud customers call us after years on an established platform is the file.
GiveSmart's Raiser's Edge NXT path runs through Importacular NXT, a third-party import tool: tickets, sponsorships, and auction wins leave GiveSmart as data your team pulls into Raiser's Edge NXT after the event, mapping funds and appeals and resolving duplicates as they go.
The platform ran the night. Reconciliation afterward takes weeks.
We're the only platform that integrates directly with Raiser's Edge NXT in real time, and that's not a feature; it's the reason customers choose us.
Every guest is matched to a constituent with a 98% match rate measured across 167 organizations and 210,000 transactions; every ticket, sponsorship, winning bid, and pledge is written as its own gift with campaign, fund, package, and appeal applied the moment it lands; participants and attendance are written to the Raiser's Edge NXT event module, and a Trellis payout ID on each gift lets Finance match deposits.
There's no export, no import tool, and no middleware. The "aha" moment switchers describe isn't that our integration is better than the last one. It's that it works.
The problem
Guests hit a login screen, and the bid never happens.
Every event planner checks the same thing before anything else: can my guests use it? A guest asked to download an app or reset a password in a dim ballroom stops, and every time the login screen wins, a bid or a pledge is lost.
Trellis is text-first and mobile-first. As long as your guests can receive a text message, they can give: a text arrives, they tap the link, and their account opens with no app download, no login, and no learning curve.
The card given at registration is on file for the auction, the paddle raise, and the raffle, so nobody is asked twice.
Outbid alerts, check-in confirmations with table numbers and paddle raise prompts arrive by text, tied to what is happening in the room, and a guest with an incomplete record can pledge with a name and email.
Easy enough that nothing goes wrong on the night of. That's the standard we hold ourselves to.
The problem
The event planner is the human bridge between systems, and the whole team pays for it.
Most platforms create work before, during, and after the event. In the lead-up, colleagues chase the event planner for details that already exist in Raiser's Edge NXT and re-enter them into a backend they have to relearn every year.
On the night, staff trained once are fielding questions while the person on the hook for half a million dollars runs check-in. Afterward, everyone is pulled off their real jobs for a month of cleanup.
Trellis does the opposite. Before the event, your team pulls what it needs directly from Raiser's Edge NXT and Trellis, with no manual exports and no re-entering data that already exists.
On the night, staff walk in, and it just works, with no prior training required: hundreds of guests are checked in within minutes, and everything volunteers need is in front of them proactively, so the event planner gets to be present rather than stressed and fielding questions.
Trellis runs at 99.99% uptime, published live at status.trellis.org, and we build the product so it does not need a person from our company standing in your ballroom. After the event, the data is already where it needs to be.
The line we hear most often after a first Trellis event is a customer's: "My team doesn't dislike me anymore."
The problem
The price goes up every year, and the invoice is only part of it.
Reviewers describe the GiveSmart subscription rising considerably each year for the same service, and the subscription is not the whole number: 3.5% to 3.95% processing on a $200,000 gala is $7,000 to $7,900 on its own, and the database time after the event is on no invoice at all. At renewal, a team running one gala and one tournament is testing whether the total matches the usage.
Trellis is a flat $5,000 a year that covers every event you run, with a 0% transaction fee option so the total usually lands very close to $5,000.
Donate Auction Bid captures a losing bidder's opt-in while they are still bidding and processes the donation automatically at close, and full-page upsells lift what each checkout raises, so the platform pays for itself in revenue GiveSmart never asked the room for.
The product is deliberately focused on events, which is also a tradeoff we name below.
Interactive Product Demo
Watch a ticket, sponsorship or winning bid land in Raiser's Edge NXT within minutes.
Pricing
Trellis is $5,000 per year, flat. There's no per-event fee, no percentage of funds raised, no separate charge for the Raiser's Edge NXT integration, and no charge for onsite staff, because we don't send any. Transaction fees are 0% or 3.5% + $0.30.
With 0% Transaction Fees turned on, Trellis covers the fee on eligible checkouts under $3,000, and your guests are offered the option to add a small contribution at checkout; if they decline, we still cover it.
Checkouts over $3,000 and back-office entries through the Sales Entry System or Check-In Tool are charged at 3.5% + $0.30, and you choose whether your organization or the purchaser covers them.
Price the whole gala before you decide. On a $200,000 event, GiveSmart's annual subscription is about $3,000, and its 3.5% to 3.95% processing adds about $7,000 to $7,900, for a realistic total near $10,000 before setup or add-ons; the Pay-As-You-Go model replaces the subscription with a higher all-in rate on every transaction.
Trellis is $5,000, and with 0% fees on the total, it usually lands very close to that, because few checkouts run above $3,000.
An organization running Raiser's Edge NXT has already invested tens of thousands of dollars in its CRM; the platform that writes into it correctly is worth more than the one that hands back an import.
Full details are on our pricing page.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
We're the only platform that actually integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT in real time, and it's the reason most of our customers chose us.
GiveSmart lists Raiser's Edge as an integration; read the documentation, and it's Importacular NXT, an import tool your database team runs after the event. We actually integrate, and the integration is built and supported by us.
When a guest buys a ticket or a sponsor confirms a table, we match them to an existing Raiser's Edge NXT constituent or create a new one, searching by last name, last name plus email, and last name plus phone, and ranking every candidate across all contact information on file, so a couple never becomes two records and nothing is ever overwritten.
As the evening runs, each ticket, sponsorship, winning bid, paddle raise pledge, and donation is written as its own gift rather than a lump transaction, with campaign, fund, package, and appeal mapping applied as the gift lands, gift type and subtype set the way you want them, and fair market value and fees handled the way your Finance team configured them.
Participants and attendance are written to the Raiser's Edge NXT event module, so next year's appeal can query who actually came.
The settings run nine sections deep and cover four levels: campaign, fund, package and appeal mapping; constituent matching with spouse and household rules; the event module and participation records; and gift type.
For every one integration point most competitors offer, we have roughly twenty, and every match, gift, and participant is listed in an auditable log.
What customers tell us after their first event is not that it's better than the last integration. It's that it works.
Setup
We can move as fast as you can. Setting up banking, the Raiser's Edge NXT integration, and your first event takes one to two weeks; the six to eight weeks you'll hear from other vendors is the runway for ticket sales to run, not setup time.
Migration from GiveSmart covers contact import, item catalog import from a spreadsheet, sponsor and table setup, and a one-time Raiser's Edge NXT mapping session with your database administrator.
Prior event history stays in GiveSmart's exports; we don't import past bidding data, so export it before the contract ends.
Setup is self-guided, with in-product tutorials and training moments that walk your team through each part of the event journey, and our team available at every step with same-day email responses to every question. There's no mandatory series of onboarding calls to get through before you launch.
Event-night staff and volunteers need no platform training; onboarding is for your database administrator and event lead.
Tradeoffs
GiveSmart bundles a donor CRM with DonorSearch scoring, which suits organizations that don't already run Raiser's Edge NXT; Trellis doesn't replace a CRM, and organizations not on Raiser's Edge NXT get less of the core differentiator.
GiveSmart runs peer-to-peer and year-round campaigns, which sit outside our product. GiveSmart stores every past event's auction history in one account; we start from a clean catalog import.
We don't provide in-person or emergency day-of support, by design: the product is built so you don't need a person from a vendor in the room, and the testimonials after a first event are the reason we keep doing it.
If a vendor representative in the room is a requirement regardless, OneCause, Greater Giving and Givergy sell it, and you should budget for it.
We're not the cheapest option, and for a small event with no CRM to feed, BetterWorld or Givebutter will run the night for free. We have fewer public reviews than GiveSmart.
Support
Support is the most praised thing in GiveSmart's reviews, so we'll be direct about the difference. GiveSmart's model is chat and phone support that walks you through a backend; reviewers say they relearn every event, and an emergency after-hours line on the night.
We built Trellis so nothing goes wrong instead: 99.99% uptime, published live at status.trellis.org, check-in and checkout screens that tell volunteers what to do with no prior training, and the most robust in-product tutorials and training moments in this category.
Onboarding is for the core team, not the room, and it moves as fast as you do: the database administrator maps Raiser's Edge NXT once, the event lead builds the event with guided tutorials, and our team is available at any step by chat or screen share with same-day email responses.
On event night, your team has a direct line to a named rep on our team rather than a ticket queue. Every customer is nervous about running the night without a vendor in the room before their first event, and the first event is what changes their mind.
Mini Case Study
Blessings in a Backpack ran 284 events last year across seven chapters, and until 2025 ran them on GiveSmart.
Bryan Rurey, Director of Development Operations at Blessings in a Backpack, who has used Raiser's Edge since 1998 and spent 13 years at Blackbaud, evaluated the market knowing what he wanted: "Everything that I wanted and needed to have to do, Trellis did. The integration was the key differentiator for me. A donor goes online; they make their reservation, and it's in Raiser's Edge. No question. It really is just there."
After four events on one Saturday, his event teams were packed up and home by Monday afternoon: "That wouldn't have happened last year."
Kate Careb, Chief Advancement Officer at Child and Family Agency of Southeastern Connecticut, a GiveSmart user for years in her consulting days, made the same move three years ago: "I really didn't want to let go of it, but it was the best move I ever made."
GRACE Christian School, meanwhile, came off three disconnected systems rather than GiveSmart. Lauren Williams, GRACE's Advancement and Database Administrator, reconciled that gala in one day instead of three weeks and said the same thing about the integration from the database chair: "A lot of people will say they're integrated, but it's still import/export. Trellis is truly integrated with Raiser's Edge."
Read the full GRACE Christian School case study.
Compare the integration side by side, in your own Raiser's Edge NXT
#2
OneCause
Best Like-for-Like Replacement With Staff on SiteFundraising Tech Score: 6.1/10
OneCause, part of Bonterra, is the most recognized event fundraising platform in the sector and the closest structural match to GiveSmart: mobile bidding, events, campaigns and peer-to-peer under one contract, with the difference that OneCause still puts trained staff in the room.
Product Overview
OneCause gives you event giving sites, integrated ticketing and table management, online sponsorship sales, express check-in, silent and live auction bidding, fund-a-need with scoreboards for the room, participant messaging and peer-to-peer campaigns.
A tournament or a gala can run inside the same account, and year-round giving is available for the rest of the calendar.
Pricing
Pay-as-you-go starts at $200 per event with a 5% platform fee on funds raised, which OneCause says is capped, and the Professional Auction and Event package is $2,995 per year.
Processing is charged on top at about 4.9% all-in (OneCause states it starts at 2% on top of standard card pricing, and standard is 2.9%), and onsite staffing is quoted separately; customers who have paid for it tell us to budget $2,000 or more. On a $200,000 gala, the realistic total is $11,000 to $14,000.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
Not a native sync. OneCause's Raiser's Edge NXT integration is Importacular for OneCause, a free plug-in from Zeidman Development that runs inside the Raiser's Edge database view.
For a team leaving GiveSmart because of Importacular NXT, this is the same tool with a different export on the front of it: your team exports event data from OneCause, then imports it with a saved mapping, which is why Blackbaud Community users describe flat files going back and forth.
Setup
Sales-led onboarding, six to ten weeks for a first gala.
Tradeoffs
The annual package prices in peer-to-peer and campaign modules a one-gala team may never open, and the Raiser's Edge NXT path is the objection we hear most from Blackbaud customers.
G2 rates OneCause 4.7 across 514 reviews, with learning curve and backend confusion the most cited cons.
If you want GiveSmart's shape with a vendor in the room, it is the safest choice here.
Read our detailed comparison here: Trellis vs OneCause.
#3
Handbid
Best for Native Bidder AppsFundraising Tech Score: 5.7/10
Handbid is an auction and event platform built around native iOS and Android bidder apps, used by more than 800 nonprofits, schools, and foundations for silent, live, and hybrid auctions, with flat published pricing.
Product Overview
Handbid runs real-time mobile and web bidding with instant outbid alerts and proxy bidding; ticketing with tables and sponsorships; paddle raise and in-room donations; fixed-price items; tap-to-pay; livestream and chat; and free text-to-give with every package.
Pricing
Published flat annual pricing. The Big Event+ is $1,999 for one auction or peer-to-peer event per year. The Whole Shebang is $2,499 for unlimited events. The Whole Shebang+ is $2,999 with native apps, tap-to-pay, and full-service setup. Processing is through Stripe at about 3.5% + $0.30. On-site experts are available as an add-on.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
No Raiser's Edge NXT integration. Handbid exports bidder, ticket, and payment data as spreadsheets and offers no Blackbaud connector, so every record reaches Raiser's Edge NXT by manual import.
A team switching from GiveSmart would be trading an import tool for a raw file.
Setup
Three to six weeks, faster with the full-service setup tier. Item catalog and contact import are supported.
Tradeoffs
The auction experience is the strength, and reviewers say so: G2 rates Handbid 4.7 across roughly 220 reviews.
There's no CRM sync, so the post-event rebuild remains, and the bidder apps assume guests will download one.
For a team whose gala is really an auction with dinner attached, and whose database team can live with an import, Handbid is a strong step down in cost with pricing you can read before the call.
#4
BetterWorld
Best Free OptionFundraising Tech Score: 5.6/10
BetterWorld is a free fundraising platform with online and live auctions, raffles and giveaways, ticketing, donation forms and peer-to-peer, funded by optional donor contributions, and it's the one competitor on this page with any native Raiser's Edge NXT sync.
Product Overview
BetterWorld runs silent, live, and popcorn-style bidding, raffles, multi-tier ticketing with mobile check-in and text notifications, donation forms and peer-to-peer, and campaigns launch in minutes.
Pricing
Free Forever with optional donor contributions. Flex removes the ask for a 2.2% to 5% fee by campaign type. Partner is $1,550 per year plus 1.25%. KeyStone is $5,950 per year plus 1% and includes the CRM integration package and concierge event support.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
A very basic native sync, and the only one on this page besides ours.
BetterWorld syncs supporters as constituents and payments as gifts into Raiser's Edge NXT with fund mapping, in real time or as a daily batch, matching existing constituents by email or name and address before creating new records.
It's the CRM integration package on the paid tiers rather than the free plan, and it covers donations, tickets, and auction payments rather than event participation records, campaign and appeal mapping, or sponsorship scenarios.
Setup
Same day.
Tradeoffs
Event depth is thinner than the platforms above: table management and paddle raise controls are basic, and support on the free tier is self-serve.
Review volume is modest and skews positive on ease of use.
For a small gala with an auction and a raffle, it's a reasonable no-cost start, and for a Raiser's Edge NXT shop that only needs gifts to land under one fund, the paid-tier sync is real.
#5
Greater Giving
Best for Volunteer-Run Check-InFundraising Tech Score: 4.9/10
Greater Giving, a Global Payments company, has run school and nonprofit auctions since 1983, and its Go Time event-night interface and Auctionpay card terminals are built so volunteers can run check-in and checkout with little training.
It's one of the four platforms Raiser's Edge NXT buyers most often shortlist alongside GiveSmart.
Product Overview
Greater Giving's event software covers auctions, galas and golf tournaments.
It handles online bidding, ticketing and registration pages, sponsor and donor tracking, event-night check-in and checkout through Go Time on laptops and tablets, card payments through its Auctionpay readers, itemized receipts printed at the event, text-to-donate and video streaming, with unlimited users and events.
Pricing
Quote only. Greater Giving sells annual Event, Express and Virtual and In-Person packages with no setup fee, card processing through Global Payments and proprietary terminals, and comparison sites report a 5% platform fee alongside a monthly charge.
Greater Giving positions itself for organizations with event budgets of $50,000 or more.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
Export and import only. Greater Giving states that its event software exchanges donor data with Raiser's Edge, eTapestry, and other donor databases, and that exchange is a file export followed by an import on the Raiser's Edge side.
There's no constituent-level matching inside Greater Giving, no fund or appeal mapping applied at the moment of sale, and no event participation sync.
Setup
About one month to the first event, with a single volunteer training session on Go Time typically enough.
Tradeoffs
Ease of use is the weakest score in Greater Giving's reviews, with Capterra rating it 4.4 across 100 reviews and ease of use at 3.9.
Proprietary hardware is a strength on the night and a cost line on the invoice.
On-site staff is available for larger galas.
For a committee that wants the vendor's terminals and people at the door, it is the most established option after OneCause.
#6
Givebutter
Free Online Campaigns and Small EventsFundraising Tech Score: 4.8/10
Givebutter is a free fundraising platform funded by optional donor tips, with donation forms, peer-to-peer, event ticketing, auctions, and a built-in CRM. G2 named it the top nonprofit software of 2026.
Product Overview
Givebutter gives you event pages with unlimited ticket types and check-in scanning, silent auctions with mobile bidding and auto-charge for winners, livestream, in-person payments, and a free CRM with unlimited contacts.
Gala mechanics such as table assignment and paddle raise controls are lighter than the event platforms.
Pricing
Free when donor tips are enabled, with a default tip of about 15% shown to guests. Disable tips, and the combined rate is 5.9% + $0.30 (a 3% platform fee plus 2.9% + $0.30 processing), and auto-charging auction winners triggers the fee even with tips on.
On a $200,000 gala with tips off that is about $11,800. Givebutter Plus starts at $29 per month.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
Not native, and not free. Givebutter's Raiser's Edge NXT integration is powered by Omatic, a paid third-party platform, so the free platform's CRM sync is an add-on from another vendor.
It syncs supporters to constituents; gift sync with campaign, fund, and appeal mapping was still an open request on Givebutter's own community board in 2025.
Setup
Same day.
Tradeoffs
Free is real for online campaigns and less so for a gala, where auto-charge triggers the platform fee and a $5,000 table buyer sees a tip prompt.
G2 rates Givebutter 4.7 across 2,174 reviews.
For a small ticketed event with no CRM to feed, it is a strong free start. Read our guide to Givebutter alternatives.
#7
Givergy
Best for Fee-Funded Events With StaffingFundraising Tech Score: 4.7/10
Givergy, now part of momoGood, is a UK-founded event fundraising platform with mobile bidding, leaderboards and totalizers, prize draws and ticketing, and it bundles fundraising consultation, event staffing and consignment auction items alongside the software.
Product Overview
Givergy runs silent and live auctions with mobile bidding and sealed bids, pledge appeals with bespoke totalizers and leaderboards for the room, prize draws, ticketing, donations, and guest messaging.
After close, it sends a losing-bid conversion message to unsuccessful bidders, which Givergy reports raises an average of about $700 per event.
Pricing
Two published models. A flat 4% platform fee on total funds raised, or a donor tip model where supporters cover the fee at checkout and the platform is free to the organization. Processing applies to both.
Event staffing, consulting, and item procurement are quoted separately.
On a $200,000 gala, the 4% model is $8,000 before processing.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
Not native. Givergy offers a connector through Givergy Connect whose depth is unverified; Capterra lists Blackbaud Financial Edge NXT, the accounting product, as its only Blackbaud integration.
Bidder, winner, and pledge data reach Raiser's Edge NXT by export or through that connector, with matching and attribution in your database team's hands.
Setup
Weeks, consultant-led.
Tradeoffs
Review volume in the US is thin, and Trustpilot reviews are mixed.
The percentage model means a $500,000 gala pays $20,000 in platform fees unless tips cover it, which is the tradeoff of no annual contract.
For a team that wants staff in the room and a losing-bid prompt without a subscription, it fills a gap the others leave.
#8
Bloomerang Fundraising (Qgiv)
Best for Bloomerang CRM UsersFundraising Tech Score: 4.5/10
Bloomerang Fundraising, formerly Qgiv, is the fundraising layer of the Bloomerang Giving Platform with donation forms, events, peer-to-peer, auctions, and text giving built to feed Bloomerang CRM.
Product Overview
Bloomerang Fundraising covers event registration and ticketing, mobile auctions, fund-a-need and text fundraising, with auctions and peer-to-peer in the Pro tier.
It says it can run galas, and the gala mechanics are lighter than GiveSmart's or OneCause's.
Pricing
From $40 per month, billed annually for forms, events, and text giving. Auctions and peer-to-peer are in the quote-only Pro tier. Bloomerang CRM is $125 per month.
Transaction fees apply.
Raiser's Edge NXT Integration
Not native. Bloomerang Fundraising offers a Raiser's Edge connection through Omatic's ImportOmatic, a paid third-party tool, as a scheduled export mapped by default fund, campaign, appeal, and event values.
It works, and Bloomerang's commercial position is to replace Raiser's Edge rather than to feed it.
Setup
Days for forms, a few weeks for a first event with auction.
Tradeoffs
Everything routes through Bloomerang CRM, which is the point for its users and a migration for everyone else.
Some reviewers describe event-night reliability issues on the legacy Qgiv auction tooling and paid card readers.
G2 rates it 4.7 across 276 reviews.
A GiveSmart customer on Raiser's Edge NXT would be changing CRMs to make this work.
How We Built This Guide
We started with the renewal conversation that brings teams to this search. A subscription quote higher than last year's. Raiser's Edge NXT data arriving through an import tool. A backend relearned every event. Onsite staff no longer standard. A new Pay-As-You-Go model to price against the annual plan.
An event date that doesn't fit the incumbent's timeline. Free platforms suddenly on the shortlist beside enterprise software.
We verified pricing against each vendor's published pricing page or review-site listing in November 2026, read integration documentation to separate a real-time sync from an import tool, and used G2, Capterra, Software Advice, TrustRadius, and the Blackbaud Community for recurring patterns rather than single complaints.
We were deliberate about being fair to GiveSmart, and the section on when to stay is not a formality.
This guide is for a Director of Development and an events coordinator reading together at renewal, with a database administrator checking the integration claims and an executive director weighing the annual contract against events per year.
What to Look For in a GiveSmart Alternative
A switcher already knows what event software does. What you need to know is what it costs to move, and whether the replacement fixes the thing that prompted the search.
1
A Real-Time Sync Into Raiser's Edge NXT, Not Another Import Tool
If the reason you're leaving is Importacular NXT, make sure the replacement isn't Importacular for OneCause.
Ask each vendor to show a winning bid landing on a constituent record with the appeal attached, live, during the demo.
Only Trellis, our own platform, does this natively among the eight; BetterWorld syncs gifts under one fund on its paid tiers.
2
Data Migration and What Does Not Move
If you have a decade of auction history in GiveSmart, ask each alternative what imports: contacts yes, item catalog usually, sponsors and tables sometimes, historical bidding data almost never.
Export everything from GiveSmart before the contract ends, because access typically ends with it.
3
The Annual Plan Against Pay-As-You-Go, on Your Numbers
If price drove the search, price GiveSmart's two models and each alternative for one, two, and three events a year, including processing and any percentage of proceeds.
A flat annual fee wins at two events or more; a percentage model wins only when the events are small.
4
Contract Timing and Mid-Season Cutover
If your gala is in the spring and renewal is in the fall, map each vendor's time-to-first-event against the date.
Self-serve tools can be live in days; sales-led platforms need six to ten weeks; Trellis is one to two weeks, including the Raiser's Edge NXT mapping.
5
A Support Model You Have Chosen Deliberately
If onsite staff is what you'll miss, decide whether you want it replaced with a vendor in the room (OneCause, Greater Giving and Givergy sell it) or with a platform your own volunteers can run with no prior training (Trellis).
Both work; they cost differently and leave your team in a different place next year.
6
Gala Mechanics Pressure-Tested Side by Side
If your gala has 400 guests, test table assignment, check-in throughput, paddle raise controls, overtime bidding, outbid alerts, and end-of-night checkout on each shortlisted platform before you sign.
Giving platforms are where these are thinnest.
GiveSmart Alternatives Pricing Comparison
Cost per event, not headline price, is the comparison that matters at renewal. GiveSmart's own two models frame it: about $3,000 a year plus 3.5% to 3.95% processing, or Pay-As-You-Go with no annual fee and a higher all-in transaction rate.
The alternatives fall into flat annual fees, per-event packages plus a percentage, percentage-only models, and free tiers that convert to a fee when tips are off.
Processing fees of roughly 2.9% to 3.5% apply on every platform except where noted and are included in the $200K totals below.
Pricing as of November 2026. Contact each vendor directly for current information.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best GiveSmart alternative in 2026?
For organizations on Raiser's Edge NXT, Trellis, our own platform, is the best GiveSmart alternative because it's the only event platform that actually integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT in real time, and it's a flat $5,000 a year with a 0% fee option.
For a like-for-like replacement with a vendor in the room, OneCause is the closest match. Handbid is the best pick for native bidder apps, and BetterWorld is the best free option.
Why do nonprofits switch away from GiveSmart?
Three patterns recur in reviews: the annual price rising at renewal for the same service, Raiser's Edge NXT data arriving through an import tool rather than a sync, and a backend that has to be relearned each event alongside the end of standard onsite staffing.
None is a claim that the platform runs auctions badly; reviewers consistently praise its support, and Bryan Rurey at Blessings in a Backpack, who left it, says on record that it did everything he asked of it except save him the weeks of data entry.
How much do GiveSmart alternatives cost?
From free to about $14,000 at a $200,000 gala, all in. BetterWorld and Givebutter are free with donor tips. Handbid runs $1,999 to $2,999 a year plus processing. Trellis is $5,000 flat with a 0% fee option. OneCause lands at $11,000 to $14,000 with processing and staff.
Givergy charges 4% of funds raised. Greater Giving is quote only. GiveSmart itself is about $10,000 on the annual plan at that event size.
Does GiveSmart integrate with Raiser's Edge NXT?
Through an import tool. GiveSmart lists Blackbaud Raiser's Edge among its integrations, and the documented path is Importacular NXT, a third-party tool from Zeidman Development that pulls GiveSmart data into Raiser's Edge NXT with a saved mapping after the event.
Matching and fund mapping happen in the tool, and event participation records aren't created. Ask GiveSmart to show a winning bid landing on a constituent record live, and ask any alternative to show the same.
Which GiveSmart alternative integrates with Raiser's Edge NXT?
Trellis, our own platform, in real time at constituent, gift, campaign, fund, package, appeal, and event participation level.
BetterWorld syncs constituents and gifts under one fund on its paid tiers. OneCause uses Importacular, the same import tool GiveSmart does. Givebutter and Bloomerang Fundraising route through Omatic's paid tools. Handbid, Greater Giving and Givergy rely on exports or an unverified connector.
Can I migrate my auction history out of GiveSmart?
Partly. Contacts, sponsors, and item catalogs export as spreadsheets and import into most alternatives.
Historical bidding data and past event pages generally don't transfer as live records anywhere; they become exports you keep.
Export everything before the contract ends, because platform access typically ends with it.
Is GiveSmart's Pay-As-You-Go plan a reason to stay?
It can be. Launched in September 2026, it removes the annual subscription in exchange for a higher all-in transaction rate disclosed at signup, which suits a small or new program.
For an organization raising $200,000 or more through events, a percentage on every transaction usually costs more than a flat fee, and it doesn't change how data reaches Raiser's Edge NXT. Price both models on your own numbers.
When should a nonprofit stay on GiveSmart?
When you're not on Raiser's Edge NXT and want the bundled donor CRM, when peer-to-peer and year-round campaigns are a real part of the program, when a decade of auction history in one account matters to you, and when the chat and phone support that reviewers praise is what your team relies on.
GiveSmart's Pay-As-You-Go option also means a team overpaying for an annual plan may only need a different plan.
500+ galas · $150M+ raised
Close the gala and the reconciliation on the same night
See how Trellis writes every ticket, sponsorship and winning bid into Raiser’s Edge NXT in real time.
“My team doesn’t dislike me anymore.” — Trellis customer